Differences between Feudalism and Manorialism

Last Updated on March 19, 2022 by QCity Editorial Stuff

Feudalism and manorialism are two types of economic systems. Feudalism is an economic system in which land was owned by nobles who granted people the right to use the land for a certain period. Manorialism is an economic system in which lords shared common rules and customs with their vassals, typically peasants or serfs. The peasants were usually bound to the land and had very little if any, personal property.

Feudalism dates back to the early Middle Ages when it was originally a practical system in which land-owning nobles granted land to their military subordinates in return for the duty of protection. These “vassals” would then grant pieces of their land to “serfs,” who maintained the land and supplied materials in return for protection and agricultural produce. The structure was essentially feudal.

Feudalism and manorialism are both types of medieval European socio-economic systems. Feudalism is a system in which the rights to work on or own land, produce goods, or collect revenue are granted by the king to his knights. These rights are then sub-granted by the knights to peasants, who owe rent and services to the lord. Manorialism is a type of agricultural society where the land is given out in return for military service.

Comparison between Feudalism and Manorialism

Parameters of Comparison  FeudalismManorialism
Engagefeudalism people engage in agriculturemanorialism they engage in trade
AuthorityIn feudalism, the landlord has complete authority of their land,manorialism anyone can make use of the land as long as they have the permission of the landlord.
Economyfeudalism the rural economy relies on barterThe manor is self-sufficient in the manorial economy
FreeIn feudalism, the serfs are not freemanorialism they are free from serfdom

What is Feudalism?

Feudalism is an ancient political system that was the predominant organizational system for much of Europe from the 5th through the 15th centuries. The feudal system created a nobility class that owned all the land, which was then sub-divided into smaller parcels that were given to vassals who pledged their loyalty to the king/landlord in exchange for protection and support. Feudalism was characterized by a set of reciprocal legal and military obligations among the warrior nobility.

Feudalism was a historical system of government that used a hierarchy of lords and vassals. Lords were at the top of the social order, and from them, the land was granted to an individual or family to form a manor. In return for the land, the lord received loyalty from their vassals in return for protection and care. The Monarch maintained control by allocating privileges and responsibilities through honorific titles.

Feudalism is a hierarchical system in which vassals swear allegiance to lords and kings, who pledge faith and protection in return. It was an economic and social organization spanning centuries of European history. Feudalism was at its height between the 9th and 13th centuries and played a significant role in shaping modern-day Europe and the rest of the world.

Differences between Feudalism and Manorialism

What is Manorialism?

Manorialism is a term that refers to the social system prevalent in much of the Middle Ages. A manor typically consisted of a large house, surrounded by village-like settlements called villeins; it was not uncommon for the population living on the manor to number in the hundreds. The landowner generally held power over his peasants, overseeing work and services such as rent, labor, and livestock.

Manorialism is a system of society and economy in which the manor – the whole estate – serves as a unit of production under the control of a feudal lord. The word “manorial” was first used to describe the way land and peasants were treated on medieval estates or manors. The lord of the manor had total control over his territory, including all population and building, even down to rights to animals and hunting.

Manorialism is a term that refers to the social system prevalent in much of the Middle Ages. A manor typically consisted of a large house, surrounded by village-like settlements called villeins; it was not uncommon for the population living on the manor to number in the hundreds. The landowner generally held power over his peasants, overseeing work and services such as rent, labor, and livestock.

Differences between Feudalism and Manorialism

10 Differences between Feudalism and Manorialism

1. The main difference between Feudalism and Manorialism is that in feudalism people engage in agriculture, while in manorialism they engage in trade.

2. In feudalism, the landlord has complete authority of their land, while in manorialism anyone can make use of the land as long as they have the permission of the landlord.

3. The manor is self-sufficient in the manorial economy, while in feudalism the rural economy relies on barter.

4. In feudalism, the serfs are not free, while in manorialism they are free from serfdom.

5. In feudalism, the peasants support the landlord, while in manorialism it is the opposite.

6. The manorial system was based on the obligations to the Lord of the Manor.

7. There was a hierarchy in the feudal system i.e. kings, lords, and vassals.

8. The manorial system was based on the transfer of land rights to the lord of the manor.

9. The lord of the manor paid for his military force.

10. In manorialism the peasants paid.

Interesting Statistics or Facts of  Feudalism

1. The Feudal system in Europe developed in the Early Middle Ages.

2. Feudalism was an economic system where land was controlled by military leaders.

3. The control over the land was passed down from generation to generation.

4. The system of Feudalism was not efficient and was replaced by Capitalism.

5. Although Feudalism was replaced by Capitalism, it still has some influence on our society today.

6. There are a lot of similarities between Feudalism and Modern Capitalism.

7. The biggest difference between Feudalism and capitalism is that Feudalism was a system where the land was controlled by military leaders while capitalism is a system where land is controlled by the government.

Interesting Statistics or Facts of Manorialism

1. Manorialism was a way of life in the feudal system.

2. In the manorialism system the land was owned by the lord of the manor.

3. The peasants were bound to the land.

4. The peasants had to work for the lord of the manor.

5. The manorial system depended on the feudal system.

6. The manorialism system was predominant during the middle ages.

7. The manorial system was abolished on the 1st of July, 1916.

8. In the manorial system the peasants had to deliver certain crops to the lord of the manor.

9. The manorial system was used to pay the workers for coins and food.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the differences between Feudalism and manorialism are vast. The feudal system eventually led to the formation of manorialism, which is where lords could own land and what was on it. This system also allowed for the lord to require goods and services from the peasants.
Manorialism is a type of feudal system that emerged in medieval Europe, where noblemen owned land and could require goods or services from peasants.

References:

Resource 01: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feudalism
Resource 02: https://www.thoughtco.com/what-is-manorialism-4706482

Scroll to Top